28th November 2007

What’s Better to Build Community: Blogs or Forums?

How Blogs and Forums are Different

  • Open Publishing vs Structured Publishing
    Blogs usually do not require users to register to read or comment. Some forums may be restricted to write, or even read. Blogs are a pure publishing vehicle, whereas forums are often geared around knowledge management or networking. Of course there are varying degrees of forum control, from completely open, to invite only. 99% of the time there are guidelines, moderators and rules in forums, where a blog may often have none.

  • Forums: Structured Conversation
    Typically there are social constructs with forums, content may be limited and moderated by a specific subject group (often, blogs are decentralized content, forums are centralized content) Forums often have moderators and referees, whereas blogs do not.

  • Forums: Knowledge Management, Collaboration, Discussion, Networking
    Forums are more geared towards queries: asking, harvesting, and managing knowledge. In my experience with forums, many topics may be a stated opinion, or posed question requesting response and answers. Blogs may not always be question or collaborative in nature. Generally speaking, the content purpose of many blog posts is to inform or persuade, it may not be to ask or seek response.

  • Blogs: Hello World!
    Blogs are a great way to initiate a conversation into a market, especially if that market does not consider you a trusted source. It’s more likely than not, that members of a forum are already part of a circle of knowledge or trust. Blogs may be the first footstep to entering that trusted network.

  • Blogs are Persuasive and stand out in the noise
    Blog publishing is limited to a small group that may have a specific goal or intent for it’s intended audience. The author can more easily guide the blog conversation towards a common strategy and goal. Forums, although usually topic based may involve many opinions and thoughts versus a single opinion.

  • Blogs: Pings and Trackbacks
    Most blogs automatically ping google/yahoo and other aggregators to notify sites of updates and editions, some forums may not have this feature, (however it’s rapidly coming around). The key difference is that blogs currently seek to be aggregated (found), and forums may or may not be seeking to be aggregated.

  • Blogs: My Design, My control
    Bloggers can control their experience, templates, look and feel, topics, and moderation to provide a more personalized experience vs forums design is for the managing member(s). Blog authors can control the subject, categories, and content of the blog, this holistic control is not possible in a forum.

Are Blogs a better way to create a community than Forums?

  • Each has unique features to build community, (one not better than the other) consider using both in tandem, ultimately it depends on your business and user needs.
  • In general, blogs are great at connecting and bridging to a NEW community.
  • In general, forums are great at harnessing and growing an EXISTING community.
  • Blogs have strength to reach out build or associate with a community due to it’s ping and trackback features, and publication/persuasive style of writing.
  • Forums have strength in harnessing an existing community.
  • Blogs vs Forums may be more effective in different stages of a customer cycle.

Key Takeaways

  • Each tool has a specific strength, with varying benefits depending on your situation.
  • Consider using blogs to capture community and engage community: Evangelism and the “Official Stance” of any particular subject. Consider using Blogs as a guide, a recognized message, or even an “official” point of view.
  • Use forums to build and grow communities: Knowledge Management and Networking.
  • Unless you have a specific reason, why use one? there are many tools out there that can be used in combination, a forum and a blog together can be symbiotic. Keep in mind there are many other web tools to build community, such as wikis, tagging, and other tools.
  • None of this will matter anyways, as in the future, information will be raked right off blogs and forums and consumed in user feedreaders and other aggregators. These two entities will be so closely tied that there will be a little or no visual difference.

Spread the word: bookmark it/readit

Stumble it! Del.icio.us Check out my lens

posted in SEO/Search Engine News | 0 Comments

28th November 2007

SEO Copywriting – Strengths and Weaknesses

By : Nidhi Gupta

SEO Copywriting strengths

One thing that can be said about search engine optimization copywriting is that it works for suitable websites and for suitable search terms. SEO Copywriting can achieve rankings that tend to do well across the search engines, although no page can do equally well in all engines.

It is sometimes said by practitioners of search engine optimization copywriting, that the method tends to maintain its rankings as the engines tweak and change their algorithms, whereas other methods produce less stable rankings. This can’t be true. If 2 pages are in the top 10 search results; one getting there by the SEO copywriting method and the other by different search engine optimization techniques, they are both there because they match the engine’s criteria (algorithm) quite well. When the criteria is changed, the match that each of them had is necessarily changed. The matches could become closer to, or further from, the engine’s criteria. Whether each page goes up or down in the results depends on what changes have been made to the engine’s criteria. It is a matter of chance, and not a matter of whether SEO copywriting was used or not.

SEO Copywriting weaknesses

  • Competitive search terms
    The technique only works for search terms that are not particularly competitive. Competitive search terms are those where many people are trying very hard to gain the top rankings for their sites. Casino, sex, insurance, health and hotels sites are among the most competitive, and there are many other topics where people fight for rankings. For medium to highly competitive search terms, other, more vigorous, methods are needed.

  • Suitable sites
    Not all websites are suitable for SEO Copywriting. Many simply don’t have sufficient text on their pages, and adding text would spoil the design or nature of the sites. Also, some sites that do have sufficient text sometimes don’t want to be forced into changing what is written on the pages, just for the sake of the search engines.

  • Read the rest of this entry »

    Stumble it! Del.icio.us Check out my lens

    posted in SEO/Search Engine News | 0 Comments

    • Subscribe

    • Add to Google
    • Add to My Yahoo!
    • Subscribe with Bloglines
    • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
    • Add to Technorati Favorites!
    • Feedburner Reader
    • Get free E-Book on blogging

    • Online Marketing
    • RSS


    eXTReMe Tracker